Skip to main content

Bagel Choices

- Plain            - Pumpernickel
- Everything       - Asiago
- Onion            - Honey Wheat
- Garlic           - Rye
- Salt             - French Toast
- Egg              - Egg Everything
- Multigrain       - Blueberry
- Bialy            - Flagel
- Sesame           - Jalapeno Cheddar
- Poppy            - Cinnamon Raisin


Build-a-Bagel

Start with your choice of bagel ($2.08)                 and add whatever you like! 


• Butter - $1.04
• Cream Cheese - $2.08
(Plain, Honey Walnut, Jalapeño, Scallion, Veggie, Strawberry)
• Salmon Cream Cheese - $4.16
• Peanut Butter - $2.08
• Jelly - $1.04
(Strawberry/Grape) 
• Bacon/Sausage/Turkey/Ham - $3.38
• Taylor Ham/Corned Beef/Steak - $4.16
• Egg - $1.25
• Cheese - $1.08
(American/Swiss/Provolone/Cheddar)
• Lettuce/Tomato/Onion/Spinach - $0.52
• Avocado - $2.08
• Salt/Pepper/Ketchup – FREE.99
• Mustard/Brown Mustard/Mayo – FREE.99 


Bagels In A Bag

Each • $2.08

1/2 Dozen • $10.40

Dozen (15) • $26

Dozen w/ Two Spreads • $36


Cream Cheese

8oz Plain • $6

8oz Scallion, Jalapeno, Veggie, Honey Walnut, Strawberry • $6.50

8oz Salmon Cream Cheese • $8



Breakfast Sandwiches

On Your Choice of Bagel or Bread
(Made With American Cheese)

Liberty • $7

2 Eggs & Cheese

The Big Apple • $9

2 Eggs, Bacon & Cheese

Staten Island • $9

2 Eggs, Sausage & Cheese

Central Park • $9

2 Eggs, Ham & Cheese

Jersey Shore • $9

2 Eggs, Taylor Pork Roll & Cheese

Manhattan • $9

2 Eggs, Steak & Cheese

Brooklyn • $10

2 Eggs, Pastrami & Cheese

Yonkers • $10

Avocado, Tomato, Homemade Pesto 
& Balsamic Drizzle (Served Open Faced)

Hells Kitchen • $12

2 Scrambled Eggs, Shaved Ribeye Steak, with 
Salsa Fresca & Jalapeno Cream Cheese

The Nolita • $12

2 Scrambled Eggs, Turkey, Avocado, 
Spinach & Chipotle Sauce

Governors Island • $13 

Nova Salmon, Cream Cheese, Capers, Red Onion, Tomato

    




LUNCH Sandwiches

NY Cheesesteak • $14

Shaved Ribeye Grilled with Peppers & Onions, Topped with Provolone Cheese

Roosevelt Island • $14

Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut & Homemade 1000 Island Dressing

New Yorker • $15

Hot Pastrami, Melted Swiss Cheese with Grilled Onions and Deli Mustard

West Village • $12

Homemade Chicken Salad served with Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Banana Peppers & Provolone Cheese

Upper East Side • $12

Homemade Tuna Salad served with Lettuce, Red Onion, Tomato, Capers and Scallion Cream Cheese









By The Pound

Potato Salad • $10/lb

Sweet Potato Salad • $10/lb

Pasta Salad • $10/lb

Nova Salmon • $28/ lb

Chicken Salad • $20/lb

Tuna Salad • $20/lb

Egg Salad • $13/lb


East Village • $10

Homemade Egg Salad with Lettuce & Homemade Pickles

Van Cortlandt • $12

Chicken, Bacon & Cheddar served with Lettuce, Tomato & Homemade Pesto

Greenwich Grilled Cheese • $10

American Cheese, Tomato & Crispy Bacon

BLT • $10

Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo

Tribeca Caesar Wrap • $12

Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon Pieces, Parmesan Cheese, Homemade Bagel Croutons, Lettuce & our delicious Homemade Caesar Dressing!

Koreatown Wrap • $14

Lemongrass Steak with Shaved Carrots & Red Cabbage, Cucumber, Cilantro, Lettuce & Spicy Mayo




Sides

Chips, Pasta Salad, Potato Salad, Sweet Potato Salad



Drinks

Small Coffee • $2
Large Coffee • $3
Coca-Cola Product • $3
Bottled Water • $2
Smart Water • $3
Natalie's Juices • $3.25
Chocolate Milk • $3 

Contact Us

Handmade dough + kettle boiled + fresh baked daily = the most authentic NY bagels in SWFL! Our "Bronx Baker" uses his 40 years of experience to bring you the most delicious bagels on the daily. Come taste the difference! - That NY Bagel Place 

Address
24830 S Tamiami Trl, Ste 2100 Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Email
thatnybagelplace@gmail.com

Business Hours
Monday to Friday • 6:00 am to 2:00 pm
Sat to Sunday • 7:00 am to 2:00 pm

Thank you for sending your message.

Stay in the Bagel Loop!

Don't miss out on our latest bagel creations, exclusive offers, and mouthwatering updates. Subscribe to our newsletter today and join the NY Bagel Place community. We'll deliver the deliciousness straight to your inbox.

Thank you for sending your inquiry and we will get back to you soon.